Frank Baker (Enid Buzz), Cindy Allen (Enid News & Eagle) and April Danahy interview attorney Stephen Jones about the Karen Sue Caton case. This is a special episode uncovering Enid's past in conjunction with the BuzzHead Radio Podcast.

Caton was a 42-year-old Enid woman charged with first-degree murder. She was found guilty of the lesser charge of first-degree manslaughter for her part in the slaying of an Enid realtor. She was given a four-year prison term. She served four months.

Caton, an Enid homebuilder and wife of an Enid lumber yard dealer, was accused of hiring Dennis Olen Coggin for $300 to beat up and castrate Enid realtor Jack Krichmar, who owed her money. Krichmar was fatally stabbed in the attack.

An Oklahoma County jury found Coggin guilty of first-degree murder and sentenced him to life in prison, rejecting Stocker's argument that he be given the death penalty.

Enid lawyer Stephen Jones, Caton's lawyer, argued that Caton hired Coggin to rough up Krichmar but did not want him killed or castrated.